Write the process before choosing the person.Decide which neutral criteria you will use and apply them consistently.

Start with a complete application

Collect only information that is appropriate for evaluating the rental arrangement. Explain how the information will be used, stored, and protected.

Verify the basics

Use a reputable screening service

Compare services based on consent procedures, data security, dispute support, clear reporting, pricing, and guidance for lawful use. Do not ask applicants to send sensitive documents through ordinary email.

Have a compatibility conversation

Screening reports do not explain daily living habits. Discuss schedules, guests, cleanliness, noise, smoking, pets, shared supplies, privacy, and how each person handles conflict.

Respect housing requirements

Federal, state, and local rules may affect advertising, questions, screening, decisions, notices, and recordkeeping. Rules can differ for owner-occupied homes, but exceptions are specific and should not be assumed.

Document the decision.Keep a brief record of the neutral criteria used for each applicant. Avoid notes about personal characteristics that are not relevant to the rental.